Does History Repeat itself..?
This is an elementary definition of how History is defined. History, a discipline that studies the chronological record of events, usually attempting, on the basis of a critical examination of source materials, to explain events (Encyclopedia Brittanica). Eventually, we can observe that a sequence of historical events recurs in the course of historical time. We can see similar events, similar central figures, and similar circumstances emerging time and again. Why is this happening? Human responsibility is the key element when dealing with issues that play a central role in history. When making decisions, this is very crucial to go beyond our limitations and adopt a perspective that transcends narrow stereotypes and demonstrate an altruist and consensual approach. Usually, our national interests prevent us from being more world–oriented and that above them there is something bigger that needs to be stressed, if we want to live in a world of peace and not a world of conquest and predation. As the old proverb indicates: “You can't have your cake and eat it too.” But in world affairs we often forget about justice and norms. Compromise in front of challenges and the desire to find solutions should be our guide, if we want to achieve unity and agreement and avoid conflicts and warfare.
If history evolves in such a way that conflicts are resolved, and that peace is established through mutual understanding and cooperation, then history does not need to repeat itself. It’s only then when nations fail to work together, and conflicts cannot be resolved peacefully that war is inevitable, and countries try to solve their differences through violence and the use of weapons. There are many kinds of causes when it comes to war, but one main reason is conquest and territorial differences or even the need for “vital space” to mention just a few of them. “Wars end when nations agree that war is an unsatisfactory instrument for solving their dispute; wars begin when nations agree that peaceful diplomacy is an unsatisfactory instrument for solving their dispute. Agreement is the essence of the transition from peace to war and from war to peace, for those are merely alternating phases of a relationship between nations.” ― Geoffrey Blainey, The Causes of War. Very often, wars do not express the public mind, but the mind of individuals who happen to possess the power, the politicians and the military establishment.
Nations should implement all means in order to improve their relationships with their neighboring countries, their allies, and the larger world community. When their attempts to forge good relations and peace fail, that signifies that the purpose was not achieved, and that everything was in vain. In such a case, repetition is inevitable. The purpose won’t change, and history is forced to give another chance in the future. By doing so, the vision is to create a world that is safe, peaceful, and a better place for all. Patterns of repetition we can find in the history of Israel that was scattered to all corners of the world in the diaspora but was re-established after almost 2000 years in 1948 in Palestine. There are examples about the Rise and Fall of nations that testify about this pattern of repetitions in the examples of Greece and Rome and their empires. Both empires experienced a Golden Age with many conquests and expansion and soon after there came a decline and collapse, but they didn’t disappear. After a time of subjugation and trials, they didn’t lose their history, language and identity but re-emerged as new entities with their print and conscience. This phenomenon is astonishing and shows that repetition in history is real. “Those who cannot learn from history are doomed to repeat it.” – Winston Churchill
History is a narrative of events recorded which show evidence of real happenings. According to the Scriptures, human beings have origin, purpose and destination. The world and the Universe have a Creator, God gave human beings life, truth and responsibility. Great philosophers like Aristotle – who shared similar views with Socrates and Plato, Descartes etc. - portrays God as Prime Mover and grants Him the authority of a Supreme Being who exists beyond matter. According to Bible, God created man in His image, which means that God encapsulates the dual characteristics of masculinity and femininity. By extension that translates that God is a parental figure and not only Father. That being said, God is present in human history and expects man to fulfill his responsibility and establish a world of peace (Kingdom of God on earth). Recurring cycles of historical events will always be as long as we human beings fail to establish a better world, a world of peace. Only when we accomplish our responsibility by acting justly and wisely, can we expect God’s assistance. And this fact has been demonstrated in history time and again.
What is then the pattern and logic of historic recurrence? As stated before, it needs to be perceived as a requirement of the absoluteness of the Creator which aims at man and his vocation to achieve the supreme standard of administration and stewardship to the world. Until we have been capable of establishing permanent peace on earth, such phenomena as the rise and fall of empires and historic recurrences will probably be repeated. If we keep failing not to learn from history, we are doomed to repeat it, and this is both tragic and frustrating. Human beings, when aligned with God’s will and his ideal of a peaceful, prosperous world; will be able to achieve that goal.